Comment from: Steve Hyland [Visitor] Email
It's not totally true that rheostat dimmers simply convert excess energy to heat. They can yield significant power savings.

What they do is reduce the voltage to the bulb, which reduces the current through it. Voltage x Current = Wattage. So when a rheostat cuts the voltage to the bulb by 50% the current is reduced to 50% as well, resulting in 1/4 the power usage at the bulb and 1/4 at the rheostat for a 50% savings. Thus a 100-watt bulb would use 25 watts at the bulb and 25 watts at the rheostat, at this setting.

50% voltage is the worst case for the poor rheostat in terms of heating up, so the picture is rosier at higher or lower settings, in terms of wasted heat at the rheostat.
01/30/11 @ 04:19
Comment from: quixjote [Member]
This would be true, except you are not reducing the amount of energy used at all. It appears that you are reducing the energy because the bulb itself is using less energy, so you still get the visual difference, but the energy still has to pass through the rheostat dimmer to get to the light.

At the lowest load, you get the brightest light, but as the energy has to pass through a larger resistance, you see less light, but you get minimal difference on the source end.

If you want an experiment, hook a meter up to even a battery powered light source on a potentiometer. Hook the meter up both before and after the potentiometer. You will find that the power that goes from the potentiometer to the light will be less, but the power being drawn from the source TO the potentiometer will be almost the same. After time you will also notice that your potentiometer will start to get warm ;)

No, where the savings come in is the TRIAC based electronic dimmer. they literally toggle the power (Literally turn off and on) to the light source at a rate fast enough to that we can see a solid light, but at a variable control to allow us determine (how long) the bulb is turned on.

We do not see the results because on the light side of the TRIAC there is usually up to a 100nF capacitor that is used for discharge for those short moments when the TRIAC is switched to off.
01/30/11 @ 11:21
You Must Log-In to Post Comments.
« Google's DecisionEnergy Tip 5 - A Watched Pot »